What changes
A fee based on a percentage of assets under management has always paid for two things together: the groundwork behind the advice and the judgement in it. Once AI carries the research, the file notes, the first draft of a suitability report and much of the investment monitoring, the groundwork takes a fraction of the time it did. The judgement doesn’t shrink in the same way. A percentage fee can’t separate the two, so as the groundwork shrinks it gets harder to say what the fee is for.
Repricing means charging for the service itself: a monthly or annual subscription, or fixed fees for defined pieces of work, published so a client can read, compare and agree to them. Scaling means using the hours freed in Move 3 to serve more households, including those whose assets were too small for a percentage fee to work.
Why it matters now
Under the Consumer Duty, firms have to show that what a client pays is fair value for what they receive. The FCA has also looked closely at ongoing advice services, and at whether clients paying ongoing fees receive the reviews they pay for. A fee that rises with the portfolio while the work stays the same is harder to defend each year. A published fee tied to a defined service is easier to evidence.
Firm value is part of this too. Advice firms have usually been valued as a multiple of recurring fees. If those fees become harder to justify, the value built on them is less secure than it looks. Subscription income tied to a clear service gives the firm a steadier base.
Checklist
- Cost the service for each client band using the Move 1 time log and the hours saved in Move 3, at your true cost per hour.
- Define two or three service levels and write down what each includes, how often you meet and what’s out of scope.
- Draft a fee scale and test it with five clients across your bands. Ask what they’d expect to pay for each level and why.
- Record the fair value case for each level in your Consumer Duty assessment before anything is published.
- Move new clients first, then offer existing clients the new basis face to face at their next review and confirm it in writing.
Illustrative example
A four-adviser firm looks after £120m for 400 households and charges 0.75% a year. That brings in £900,000 of ongoing fees, an average of £2,250 per household.
After costing its service and moving the legwork to AI, it tests two published annual subscriptions. Core planning at £1,500 for 250 households brings in £375,000. Full planning, including tax work, at £3,000 for 150 households brings in £450,000. The total is £825,000, which is £75,000 less than today.
The firm doesn’t switch yet. The hours freed in Move 3 give each adviser room for more households. Either 25 more full-planning households at £3,000, or 125 households on a new £50-a-month digital tier built around its client hub, would close the gap. The firm starts with new clients and plans to offer existing clients the new basis over the following year. The figures are invented to show the method and aren’t a benchmark or a recommended fee.
Common mistakes
- Repricing everyone at once. Move new clients first, then existing clients at their next review, so you can adjust the scale as you learn what works.
- Setting fees without costing the service. A fee scale that isn’t built on real hours can’t be defended at review or in a fair value assessment.
- Cutting the fee without changing the work. Repricing only holds up once the groundwork has moved to AI and the freed capacity is real.
Coaching your clients
A clear subscription makes it easier to talk about more than the portfolio. Clients approaching retirement, changing careers or supporting older parents often need help with decisions that have little to do with fund selection, such as when to stop work or how to help children without leaving themselves short. Build these conversations into each service level. Life planning around health, longevity, family and work is where a person adds most once AI is running the portfolio, and it’s what a subscription client can see they are paying for.